Monday, November 16, 2026

News

Warsaw Court Rules AI-Cloned Voice in Ad Violated Voice Actor's Personal Rights

PolicyPatryk Raba
Warsaw Court Rules AI-Cloned Voice in Ad Violated Voice Actor's Personal Rights
Fot. Adrian Grycuk, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0 pl)

The Warsaw Regional Court ordered JFC Polska to take down an ad featuring a voice strikingly similar to that of voice actor Jarosław Łukomski and to pay a total of more than PLN 47,000. The November 13 ruling is not yet final.

Contents
  1. What the court decided
  2. The court's reasoning
  3. Positions and commentary

The Warsaw Regional Court (Sąd Okręgowy w Warszawie) has found that using an AI-generated voice strikingly similar to that of voice actor Jarosław Łukomski in an advertisement violated his personal rights. The ruling was handed down on Friday, November 13, and is not yet final.

What the court decided

The plaintiff was voice actor Jarosław Łukomski and the defendant was the company JFC Polska. The case concerned an online advertisement for household sewage treatment plants that used a digital voice model without the voice actor's knowledge or consent. The trial began in late January.

The court ordered the removal of materials containing the generated voice and banned their further use. The company must also publish an apology and cover the costs of the proceedings. The PLN 30,000 in compensation for harm was supplemented by PLN 17,280 in damages, bringing the total to more than PLN 47,000.

The awarded amounts are lower than those sought. According to RMF24, which relies on a PAP report, this was influenced in part by doubts about the methods used to value the voice actor's losses.

The court's reasoning

A court-appointed phonoscopy expert concluded that, from the perspective of an average listener, the two voices are "clearly, deceptively similar." The court characterized the ad as a deepfake, meaning material that can suggest a person is saying something they did not say.

According to rp.pl, the court sees the core of the problem as the creation of content that a person never uttered but that may be taken as authentic. What matters is how the listener perceives it, not the type of content, its quality or the size of the audience.

The court held that every person's voice is a personal right and is protected regardless of popularity. It rejected the argument of the voice actor's attorneys about a special "premium voice." According to RMF24, the judge said this is the first such dispute in Polish court practice, and that similar rulings have previously been issued in, among other places, Germany.

Positions and commentary

The company denied deliberately infringing the voice actor's rights. It pointed out that neither the voice actor's name nor likeness was used, and that it had offered a settlement. According to rp.pl, an employee of the company most likely used AI tools to generate the voice. Neither source says which tool was used.

The voice actor's attorney, Tomasz Ejtminowicz, stressed that citing external tools does not remove liability and that the principle of human oversight applies. Dr. Damian Flisak called the ruling a strong signal but warned that it could weaken the pressure to change the law.

For companies using speech synthesis in advertising, the takeaway is practical, although it comes from a single, non-final first-instance ruling: according to the voice actor's attorney, relying on an external tool does not remove liability. JFC Polska's attorneys said they would decide on next steps after consulting their client, so the final outcome may still change.

Share: